The Institute for Mathematical and Statistical Innovation (IMSI) at the University of Chicago is hosting a 10-week summer program in Chicago on “The Architecture of Green Energy Systems”. This is a trans-disciplinary program aimed at understanding the technological, social and economic challenges of transitioning to systems that generate, deliver and consume 100% renewable energy, with a view to creating an effective physical and institutional “architecture” for this transition. Participants in the program are drawn from engineering, social sciences, economics and the mathematical sciences.
The purpose of this kickoff meeting is to canvas the opinions of prominent thought leaders and researchers in renewable energy, to motivate and help shape the contents of the ensuing program. We are very interested in hearing ideas on how such systems should be designed and interact more broadly with societal needs. To be clear, the type of presentations in our first meeting will focus more on questions and problems arising from the transition rather than on solutions.
Note: IMSI will observe Juneteenth on June 19, 2024, and no workshop activity will take place on that day. The organizers have suggested a few self-organized activities that day (at participants’ own cost):
Museum of Science and Industry (https://www.msichicago.org/visit/). 9:30am – 4pm. Special exhibit: 007 Science: Inventing the World of James Bond. 20 minute walk from IMSI.
The Chicago WhiteSox baseball team (https://www.mlb.com/whitesox). 7:10pm first pitch. While not quite as successful recently as its northern neighbors, this is convenient and nicely priced. Self arranged groups can visit together and enjoy one of America’s summer pastimes. Accessible via public transit or Uber/Lyft/taxi.
This workshop is a part of the Summer 2024 long program The Architecture of Green Energy (June 17 – August 23, 2024). Acceptances to be a participant in the long program are occurring on a rolling basis.
This workshop will include a poster session. The deadline for poster proposals is has passed.
This workshop will also include daily Soap Box Talks of 5 minutes each. A soap-box talk is similar to a lightning talk but should include some speculative ideas requiring collaboration. The format is open but could include some background on the problem, some approaches tried, and some ideas of what is needed or what could be researched. The presentation should be accessible to all attendees of the meeting (all of whom are graduate level or beyond).
In order to propose a Soap Box Talk, you must first register for the workshop, and attend in-person. Proposals are still being accepted; information on how to do so will be in the welcome emails.
Systems and Institutions Modeling aspects of Green Energy
Convenor: Laura Diaz Anadon (University of Cambridge)
9:30-10:25 CDT
Demand-side solutions and their implications for feasibility and fairness
Speaker: Keywan Riahi (The International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA))
10:25-10:55 CDT
Coffee Break
10:55-11:50 CDT
Challenges to Improve Integrated Assessment Modelling
Speaker: Valentina Bosetti (Università Bocconi)
11:50-12:45 CDT
How to make climate policy modeling more decision-relevant
Speaker: Wei Peng (Princeton University)
12:45-14:00 CDT
Lunch Break
14:00-15:30 CDT
(i) Soap-box talks. (ii) Panel Discussion. (iii) Open Discussion.
15:30-16:30 CDT
Poster Session and Social Hour
Tuesday, June 18, 2024
9:00-9:15 CDT
Economics aspects of Green Energy
Convenor: Andy Philpott (University of Auckland)
9:15-10:10 CDT
The Engineering Economics of Low Carbon Electricity Market Design
Speaker: Frank Wolak (Stanford University)
Wholesale electricity markets with a significant share of intermittent wind and solar generation resources face reliability challenges relative to markets composed of dispatchable generation capacity. Reliable operation of wholesale markets with significant intermittent renewables requires a closer match between the market mechanism that sets prices and generation unit output levels and the physics of power systems operation. Simplified wholesale market models that ignore the configuration of the transmission network and operating constraints on generation units that must be respected in real-time have become increasingly costly as the share of intermittent generation in both the transmission and distribution network increases.
This talk will present several empirical analyses of the consequences of failing to adapt wholesale and retail electricity market designs to the growing amount of intermittent wind and solar generation resources. Topics considered include the design of long-term resource adequacy mechanisms, distributed versus grid-scale renewables investments, transmission and distribution network planning and expansion policies, and the design of retail pricing plans to avoid costly bypass of the grid supplied electricity. All these empirical analyses emphasize the importance of wholesale and retail market designs that account for both the physics of power system operation and the economic incentives for market participant behavior created by the market design and constraints implied by power systems operation.
10:10-10:40 CDT
Coffee Break
10:40-11:35 CDT
Scalable Data-Driven Decision-Making for Sustainable Power and Energy Systems
Speaker: Li Na (Harvard University)
Rapidly growing renewable generations and peak loads pose a serious threat to the security and reliability of modern power and energy systems. A critical question is “how to accommodate a high penetration of renewable generation and deep electrification?”. This talk studies coordinating large-scale distributed energy resources and focuses on two key challenges, including unknown information and the scalability issue. Two examples will be presented to develop distributed learning-assisted decision-making methods to address these challenges. One example is zeroth-order optimization with application to model-free optimal voltage control for handling unknown physical system models, and the other is online learning and human-in-the-loop decision-making for residential demand response to deal with unknown human user behaviors.
11:35-12:30 CDT
A decisive decade: Sustainability at Amazon
Speaker: Kommy Weldemariam (Amazon)
Amazon’s sustainability journey is fueled by science and innovation. In this talk, I’ll share our progress, challenges, and lessons learned as we tackle complex sustainability issues. From leveraging cutting-edge technologies to investing and collaborating with experts, discover how we’re driving meaningful outcomes and unlocking solutions to some of the world’s most pressing environmental and social challenges.
12:30-14:00 CDT
Lunch Break
14:00-16:30 CDT
(i) Soap-box talks. (ii) Panel Discussion. (iii) Open Discussion.
19:30-22:00 CDT
Optional Dinner (at participants’ own cost) at the Study
Sign up sheet for those interested to be completed by June 17. The Study is one block from IMSI, 1227 E 60th St, Chicago, IL 60637
Wednesday, June 19, 2024
9:00-16:30 CDT
Closed for the U.S. Federal Holiday of Juneteenth
Thursday, June 20, 2024
9:00-9:15 CDT
Modeling aspects of Green Energy
Convenor: Michael Ferris (University of Wisconsin, Madison)
9:15-10:10 CDT
Biodiversity and Climate: a Mathematical Perspective on Sustainability and Resilience
Speaker: Michel de Lara (École des ponts ParisTech)
The management of biodiversity and climate change is delicate, due to conflicts with economic development, to inertia and delayed impacts of decisions on long horizon times, and to pervasive uncertainties. This makes it a relevant area for decision under uncertainty methods. First, I will provide an overview of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) reports. Second, I will present theory and examples related to sustainability and resilience. Third, I will discuss opportunities to introduce risk measures as a way to handle riskand to design robust policies. Keyword list: sustainability, resilience, viability, stochastic optimization, risk
10:10-10:40 CDT
Coffee Break
10:40-11:35 CDT
AI Architectures for Green Energy Systems
Speaker: Pascal Van Henenryck (Georgia Institute of Technology)
Energy systems massively powered by renewable energy sources raise fundamentally novel challenges for planning and operating electrical power systems. This talk reviews how the fusion of AI and Optimization provides novel pathways to address these challenges. It will review how trustworthy AI technologies can improve forecasting and uncertainty quantification, provide order of magnitude improvements in efficiency for market operations, and enable real-time risk assessment, all which are of great interest to system operators. The talk will also report some open challenges in resource adequacy and expansion planning.
11:35-12:30 CDT
Simulation Optimization and Two-Stage Problems
Speaker: Shane Henderson (Cornell University)
In two-stage stochastic programs, a first-stage decision precedes a realization of a random outcome, which is followed by solving a recourse linear program to determine the second-stage decision. This structure is powerful, but it can be limiting. I will consider the use of (stochastic) simulation to replace the random realization and recourse linear program. The tractability of the resulting problems partly relies on the path-wise properties of the simulation model and the ability to obtain suitable gradient estimates from them. I’ll use examples to explore these issues.
12:30-14:00 CDT
Lunch Break
14:00-15:30 CDT
(i) Soap-box talks. (ii) Panel Discussion. (iii) Open Discussion.
Scalable Grid Architectures for Intelligent Electrification and Decarbonization
Speaker: Mads Almassalkhi (University of Vermont)
Decarbonization policies will require terawatts of new distributed generation, e.g., solar PV and wind, to be installed across high-voltage transmission and low-voltage distribution (T&D) systems. At times, these weather-driven, variable sources will traverse electricity networks to fully supply fleets of billions of electrified loads and distributed energy resources (DERs), including electric heat-pumps, electric vehicle chargers, and various form of energy storage. At other times, the loads and DERs will need to adapt to the available supply or regional grid bottlenecks. This adaptation will require intelligent coordination of electric DERs to defer the right amount of demand, at the right times, and in the right locations in the grid. To facilitate such intelligent electrification while guaranteeing grid reliability at all times will require combining data available to (T&D) grid operators and independent DER operators with scalable control architectures. This talk will present different architectures within the context of distributed control and optimization that facilitate integration of DER flexibility across T&D interfaces. Furthermore, since many controllable loads will reside in low-voltage networks (i.e., homes and businesses), we will discuss appropriate architectures for aggregating the capability of a fleet of DERs into responsive virtual power plants (VPPs) that are also cognizant of grid bottlenecks.
10:10-10:40 CDT
Coffee Break
10:40-11:35 CDT
How Operations Research Can Be Critical for Energy System Transition
Speaker: Andy Sun (Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT))
To combat global warming, energy systems need to go through broad and deep decarbonization in the coming decades. Electric power system plays a crucial role in leading the global energy system transition. In this talk, we will address some foundational issues in the planning and operation of electric power systems and showcase how operations research (OR) and optimization can make significant impacts by providing critical decision tools and insights. We will also discuss challenges and progresses in sustainable transitions of broader infrastructure systems, such as electrification of public transportation and capacity planning of battery recycling facilities. Finally, we will reflect on our past efforts in bridging OR to the broader scientific communities and share our outlook on future directions.
11:35-12:30 CDT
Security and Its Role in Achieving Sustainability
Speaker: Patrick McDaniel (University of Wisconsin)
It is undeniable that we are at a pivotal point in human existence. Humans as a species have grown in population and infrastructure to the point where our collective actions are impacting nearly every living thing and natural process on earth. So, what can we do to achieve a sustainable lifestyle on earth? McDaniel believes that sustainability can only be achieved when framed as a (physical and cyber) security and game theory problem. Put simply, without verifiable enforcement sustainability in the large will fail.
In this talk McDaniel will explore the economics of green initiatives and attempt to frame our collective efforts at reaching a sustainable future as one of systems under threat. Our call to action is to create a new subfield of security that addresses these threats and develops countermeasures. He will explore:
What a sub-field of security might look like
What the goals of that field would look like
What new challenges it presents
What technologies will likely be useful
How game theory will play a role
Lastly, McDaniel will revisit how future technologies can be integrated into sound policy.
12:30-14:00 CDT
Lunch Break
14:00-16:30 CDT
(i) Soap-box talks. (ii) Panel Discussion. (iii) Open Discussion.